29C3. The end of an era?

When I first heard that the annual CCC congress was moved to Hamburg, my immediate reaction was: Fine, but I wouldn't want to be involved in it. For the last 15 years I've been attending the CCC congress every year, in most years as a speaker, and in many years in some (small) contributing role, first in the team doing the video recordings, and in the last couple of years setting up a GSM network. Contributing to an event is easy if your home/lab is within 20minutes, so if you need another strange cable/adapter/tool/whatever, you can just go and grab it. Doing that at an event that's multiple hours of driving away, in a new/unknown venue is an entirely different story. I have more than enough stress already with (paid) work and the various FOSS projects that I'm leading or involved in.

I have no interest in "just" attending the event. That never was a primary reason for me. In all those years, I've probably attended an average of one talk each year. The event for me was about being able to contribute something actively.

Now, months after those thoughts and my decision not to attend, there is a schedule for the 29C3 available. And to say the least, I am shocked. The entire event seems to have turned into a SIGINT, rather than an xxC3. Lots of talks on politics and society, and lots of German talks.

The debate on implications of technology on society, culture, politics, etc. is an important debate, there is no doubt. And so far I always had the feeling that the xxC3 had a pretty good balance between hard-core technical talks and those non-technical talks. But if I look at the schedule this year, it really looks like an incarnation of the SIGINT conference. With too many German talks you are scaring off the international community. And with focussing on non technical topics, you scare away the die-hard technical hackers. So why move to a larger venue, if you at the same time seem to limit the scope of the event?

Meanwhile I have heard of a number of friends and colleagues who seem to share this view. A number of people who have attended in previous years are not interested in attending this year due to the issues mentioned above.

It's sad to see, but I somehow have the feeling that 29C3 might be the end of an era. The end of a highly successful series of events with exceptionally strong technical talks. To me, xxC3 has always been unique and special. No other event would ever compare to it. Who will fill the gap for the die-hard technical topics? I am feeling quite sad, up to the point that I want to start mourning about "the good old times".

I'm not writing this to put blame on anyone. It just reflects my personal and highly subjective view. Let's see what people will say after 29C3 has actually happened. Let's see how successful it is in terms of number of attendees, and in terms of feedback from participants. I'd like to explicitly thank the many organizers and volunteers (a lot of whom I know in person) for putting up their time and energy to make 29C3 happen.