As expected, it seems that the various different GSM cellphones expose quite big differences in their behavior towards the GSM network. In part this is due to the evolving GSM standard, where features were added over time in a backward- compatible manner, so old phones still work on modern network. The biggest part is probably due to implementation differences in the GSM stack or the particular hardware drivers that glue the stack to the given digital + analog baseband circuitry in the phone.
I have started to collect a number of different phones to test them with OpenBSC, you can see my current collection here: In addition, at the Berlin CCC we also have an old 8W Siemens P1 for testing against Phase 1 GSM phones.
The old Nokia DCT3 phones seem to be the most tolerant ones when it comes to violations of the protocol. I had a number of bugs, such as using the wrong training sequence in the CHANNEL MODE MODIFY as well as ASSIGNMENT COMMAND messages, but they simply ignored it and used the TSC from the SYSTEM INFORMATION. The various Siemens and Motorola phones are way less tolerant, which is good since it enabled me to actually find the respective bug in OpenBSC.
Also, Phase1 support in OpenBSC hasn't really been there so far. We kept asking the phones for their IMEISV, and apparently Phase1 only have IMEI but no IMEISV, leading to us rejecting the LOCATION UPDATING REQUEST. This is also fixed now. The remaining Phase1 problems are:
- correctly dealing with FR (as opposed to EFR) codec
- figure out why they send a MOBILE IDENTITY TYPE 5 instead of an IMSI on establishing a mobile-originated (MO) call